where the writers are

James GAitis Literary Satire and Historical Fiction Writer

In Search of Abbey’s Grave

July 4, 2009, 12:21 pm

James Gaitis © 2009

 

Here’s my understatement of the day:  In a literary sense, it is an exceedingly difficult challenge for all but the very best of naturalist writers to follow in the heavy bootworn footsteps of Edward Abbey.

 

Abbey, whom Larry McMurtry called “the Thoreau of the American West,” was so radically original in technique and delivery, so aggressively sincere in his unwavering belief in the value of wilderness and all that is wild, so sure of the validity of his perspective, that his works are probably viewed as too confrontational and too threatening for the vast majority of the contemporary green and greening crowd. “No Compromise in Defense of Mother Earth” was the cry of many an environmentalist in the early ‘80s. A far cry from today’s conservative post-9/11 ideology that tells us only to “Be afraid. Very afraid.” Why worry about the survival of a few endangered species, the last few unroaded areas, the last stands of oldgrowth when we have borders to protect and independence to preserve?

 

Having conceded the inevitability of Abbey’s superior abilities to dissect and declare the pathology of the American West, I am personally left with having to be satisfied with the fact that by serendipitous circumstance I seem to have followed in Abbey’s footsteps in a far more literal sense. By happy coincidence, so it seems. And perhaps due to having just a little in common.

 

Yes, like so many others, I’ve been to Arches and have walked under and around and through the same windcut desert architecture where Abbey once lived and of which he wrote of in the first pages of Desert Solitaire. And, like many another who were lucky enough to win a permit in the lottery draw, I’ve kayaked down the San Juan more or less as Abbey did to see the same remote petroglyphs and cliff dwellings and carved river canyons as he wrote about in Down the River. Like Abbey, I decry the ever-burgeoning increase in human population, unnecessary wars, uncontrolled consumption, the utter failure to maintain a long-term perspective relating to that which can only be preserved with the long term in mind. But there is more than that between Abbey and me. Call it geographical or, better yet, topographical, if you will.

 

As I now work on a series of essays (meant ultimately to be book length once compiled together) of my twelve winters off the grid in the remote North Fork in Northwest Montana—where grizzlies and wolves and lynx still roam—I find myself reminded again and again that Abbey spent a summer up in the Numa Lookout on the west flank of Glacier Park fifteen years before I arrived at that same place, on the other side of the river. I remind myself that for twelve years and more there were only three buildings I could see from my mountain home (all fire lookout towers) and that one of them for a time was Abbey’s home. I open my worn copy of The Journey Home and reread his account of his summer looming high above the pristine glacier-stained waters of Bowman Lake with Numa Peak and Rainbow, Square and Reuter, towering above, rereading his words of warning and defiance against the varied forces that would tame and erode and slowly destroy the last of our diminishing wilderness. I see again, am reminded by words written aggressively and with little regard for consequence, that we agree on many things. And I want to follow his steps in more than just a literal way.

 

And as I write, I reflect on my time living in the deserts and the mountains of New Mexico, in the staid beauty of bonny Scotland and I cannot help wonder what coincidence is this that brought both Abbey and me to these places also, and other mutual places as well. I open my battered copy of The Monkey Wrench Game, and the words jump off the page to offer combative explanations. To remind me of where my commitments should lay. Why I remain out West even though, like Abbey, I was raised east of the Mississippi.

 

And now, here on the very edge of Tucson where the deer and bobcat, coyote, javelina, snake and ringtail, coati and raccoon, an occasional bear and lion no doubt, scorpion and gila monster creep and play, where the owls great and pygmy and vultures and hawks and opportunistic birds large and small (the cardinal, the mocking bird, thrashers and hummers and giant cactus wren and woodpeckers of various size and oddly shaped) soar and swoop around the periphery of my house in search of another meal a measure of shade a respite from the heat, I find myself somehow again in Abbey’s Country. Up into the mountains just above Tucson, into the corkbacr fir and mountain maple, the tall ponderosa and high island skies that Abbey, too, knew all too well. And into the desert the canyons the arroyos, looking mostly to the ground but also into the trees always into the mountains that surround these places just as they surrounded Abbey not too many years ago.

 

And I think, perhaps I should go in search of Abbey’s grave, which I know is somewhere out in this desert, hidden somewhere in the sometimes shadows of these very mountains, laid down into the hard brittle soil beneath worn rock and blowing sand, just where he asked to be placed when he knew his time had come.

 

Which is where I leave off, where I start up anew. Searching for Abbey’s grave just as we all are in search of some place where we can be both calm and exhilarated at the same moment in time. Wanting to follow in Abbey’s footsteps, if only for a while.

 

James Gaitis

On Youtube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZ1Tan929SQ

http://www.redroom.com/author/james-gaitis

http://thenationshighesthonor.blogspot.com/2008/10/james-gaitis-new-literary-satire-to-be.html

Author of:

The Nation’s Highest Honor—A Literary Satire (Kunati Books 2009)

http://www.amazon.com/Nations-Highest-Honor-Novel/dp/1601641729/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1241031753&sr=8-1

A Stout Cord and a Good Drop­A Novel of the Founding of Montana (Globe Pequot 2006)

The View From Stansberry Lookout—A Literary Satire (Now seeking publication) 

 

Louise Young

Louise Young says:

Abbey's footsteps

Your blog brought tears to my eyes as I remembered the days when I idolized Ed Abbey -- I still have my green Earth First! t-shirt that pictures a raised fist and the "No Compromise" slogan. But one of the reasons that I split with that organization was their slavish devotion to Abbey and everything that he wrote. Almost all of what he wrote was very sexist, and in later years he was racist besides (remember the uproar about "genetically inferior" people from south of the border? He claimed it was a typo for "generically inferior" -- which to me doesn't seem a whole lot better). But my main quibble with Abbey was his breeding activity: what kind of person who loves the land would beget 6 (that we know of) little resource sinks???
This is, of course, an argumentum ad homenium (did I spell that right?) but I have another problem with Abbey -- a lot of the stuff he wrote just wasn't that good. His early writing, especially Desert Solitare and some of his fiction (notably Fire on the Mountain and The Brave Cowboy) were some of the best things that have ever been written about the American West (right up there with Stegner and McCarthy) but in later works he just trotted out that "environmentalist curmugeon" voice without really saying anything new. In other words, he whipped together something so that he could sell books to his fans (like me) who would gobble up anything he'd written. I guess he needed the money to feed his kids and pay alimony. So when I read your blog, my tears were for Abbey and what I see are his footsteps of clay, for myself and my lost idealism, and for the world that needs an environmental consciousness now more than ever --

James GAitis

James GAitis says:

Abbey's Generation Gap

Ah, yes. There's that idealism thing in me creeping up again. You are right, of course, in some (perhaps all) of your criticisms of Abbey. I've always had to read Abbey from across the gulf of a generation gap as well as a philosophical gap. He was a hunter, I'm a vegetarian. He had far too many offspring, I intentionally have none. He writes like a sexist (although I'm not sure he was one), I wouldn't dare to do that and never would want to, besides.

But I have always found the clarity of his ultimate environmental message, while sometimes not literary, to be refreshing. As were, at least for their time, the efforts of Earth First!, which I also once supported and which I still at least relate to in the sense that I personally have shared in the frustration of those that have repeatedly had close encounters with the bad faith conduct of governmental officials and the bias or incompetency of courts that act in utter disregard of multiple environmental laws and established science and even obvious logic, all relating to the preservation of the environment. In a world in which few people, including those in our own government, really care about much about the long term, Abbey's words continue to have a certain value. So, despite Abbey's shortcomings (I do hope that you are wrong as relates to racist comments), I for one am reluctant to toss my Abbey in the garbage. If I were unable to forgive or at least tolerate those with the character of Edward Abbey, I fear I might have almost nothing left to read. Aldo Leopold, we know, too had his shortcomings. But, given my love for the Gila where I also once lived (the Gila containing the nation's first wilderness area, established through Leopold's good works) I also once and a while brush off my Sand County Almanac even though I know that Leopold and I would have had little in common and that he, too, probably suffered from what is now an outdated (and very possibily, given the time in which he lived, sexist and racist) perspective.

So, with a slight modification of the old Earth First! motto, I still offer this in honor of Edward Abbey: "Stop compromising mother earth!"

And, as Abbey might have once said, Cheers.

Louise Young

Louise Young says:

coyotes

Abbey's message was beautiful -- a kind of coyote's yap of defiance and independence.   Which, I guess, was why I expected him to remain defiant and free -- and probably held him to standards that would be impossible for anyone (including Aldo Leopold) to live up to.  I don't want the coyotes in my meadow to start eating Alpo, and I think when Abbey started publishing books that were not up to his original standards, I saw him as an Alpo-eating coyote.  But I just opened my (very well worn) copy of Desert Solitaire and read a few lines and I'm not sure I'll be doing anything else for the next couple days. 

Cheers!

Chris Rodell

Chris Rodell says:

A worthy quest

Hi James,

I admire your 12 years along the North Fork. Sounds like every day was some sort of beautiful dream. And I hope you find Abbey's grave. That sounds like a book in and of itself.

Happy Independence Day!

Chris R.