Jessica Barksdale Inclan Some say heartfelt and honest, some say Harry Potter for adults with sex.

Telling the Sort-Of Truth

August 26, 2008, 6:51 am

When I was in high school, I hated it, which isn't a surprise, but I did something relatively good because of it:  I applied for the Regional Occupation Program (ROP) and ended up working at first at The Contra Costa Times and then the local Orinda paper.  I had the notion that I'd get out of some things I hated about high school, mainly most of my fellow students.  I was right about that, but the truth of having to work hard for something was still in place, so my plan ultimately failed.

So let me first say that I did about as well in ROP as I did at high school, which is to say horribly.  I cut class, making up excuses as to why I wasn't working the obituary desk.  I pretended friends were cousins and showed them all around the building, going into the massive printing area.  I smoked cigarettes behind the building.  Finally, they kicked into the small leagues, and I sat in the small office and wrote articles about local comings and goings, people and places.

It's also where I learned that I couldn't write non-fiction because I wanted to change the stories. I made up better endings for the articles because the real endings weren't good enough.   I liked fiction.  I liked to lie.  As we see daily here on redroom, Khaled Hosseini says, "Writing fiction is the act of weaving a series of lies to arrive at a greater truth."

Writing the truth seems to be the act of weaving together what is remembered to approximate what might have happened.

So here I am all these years later trying to put together  the truth, a non-fiction project, trying always to tell what happened.  I think I am telling the truth, my truth.  I'm not making up scenarios that involve rehab or my teeth.  I have not reinvented my childhood, planting myself in South Central LA, when, in fact, I grew up in Orinda.  The things I'm writing about happened to me, or so I think. 

Let me use the orange cats as an example.  Yesterday, my mother and I went out to lunch.  Earlier, she'd read my blog about the orange cats, and we talked about them as we ate.  She said, "I had forgotten that you'd brought home all the orange cats."

So had I?  Maybe not, even though I had the memory that I did, could feel them all in my carrying-home hands.  But neither of us could remember exactly where Buddy had come from, so maybe I didn't bring him home.  I think I did, but who knows? 

And she remembered a story about the first orange cat, Kitty, that I had forgotten.  A friend of mine had been holding him in her palm, and she looked down and said, "This cat is asleep!"  And when my mother told me, I suddenly remembered that, too, my friend Michelle holding the tiny sleeping kitty in her hand, the cat purring and blissed out.  That would have made my blog more interesting, and I didn't have that story to tell.

I'd also forgotten how old Eu had been when he died, though I could have researched it more fully.  But researching the past through someone else is asking them to place what they remember next to your own memory.  Is that validation?  Or texturing?

So this writing the truth thing--oft written about lately--is difficult.  I think I'm going to put a disclaimer on my finished manuscript, something like:  "I think it's true."

I think it is.

Jessica

Bob Levin.jpg

Bob Levin says:

As Wright Morris more or

As Wright Morris more or less said, "Anytime you are relying on human memory, you are writing fiction."  For over a year, I've been working on an article about events that happened over 30 years ago.  The subject gave an unpublished interview about this period in his life about 10 years ago.  A couple years after that, he had himself interviewed by a friend in order to "correct" it.  He's given me both transcripts but he's also located appointment books and lists and other esoteria from the time in order to re-correct things on the order of who was in a room when or how many pages was something supposed to me when initially discussed.  This has been going on for months while he hunts up and reviews more material. He's insistent on getting this right and I'm in awe of his effort but I'm also like "Who cares?  Who'll know?  Pick a number!  Let me get the damn thing written and I'll leave it to future generations of scholars to uncover what an error-ridden fool I was."

Evie Shockley

Evie Shockley says:

memoir is so much like fiction

I totally agree with your point! And not only are there the questions of what one remembers, but just like fiction writers, the memoirist has the prerogative (the unavoidable task!) of choosing which memories, which details, to include and which to skip over -- and makes these choices based on some of the same considerations that fiction writers use: moving forward the plot, fleshing out a character, strengthening a thematic thread, etc., etc. I enjoy teaching Maya Angelou's wonderful first autobiography, I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings, in part because it's so much fun to raise questions with my students around this topic. "Why did she decide to end the narrative with this scene?" I ask, and inevitably there are eyes that widen with the arrival of new thoughts about the plasticity of "self-life-writing" . . .

jinclan10.jpg

Jessica Barksdale Inclan says:

thanks Evie and Bob for your

thanks Evie and Bob for your comments.  You made me think that I should create a longer disclaimer, one that says:  "I did my best with research, despite impediments and roadblocks, and I made some editing and artistic choices."

More on this topic, I hope..

J

Jessica Barksdale Inclan www.jessicabarksdaleinclan.com

Belle Yang and Maggie Mae Photoshop.jpg

Belle Yang says:

Yes, you are right. I call it memoir

or the nonfiction tales of my father, but by the time he has told them and I translated and created a larger landscape from the details, the stories are fiction.

jinclan10.jpg

Jessica Barksdale Inclan says:

Here's the thing--

It's ALL fiction.  The degree is the difference.  And the title.

J

Jessica Barksdale Inclan www.jessicabarksdaleinclan.com