Depressed Thinking Distortions for Writers
I recently came across a list of Depressed Thinking Distortions and, in a stunning epiphany, realized that while I'm not depressed, historically, my relationship to my writing career has been. Ugh. I've sworn to change, to recognize my "distortions," and so far, it's working really well -- I'm catching them, and I'm feeling much better. Here's the list (I've changed the examples to make them specific to writers).
How many of these Depressed Thinking Distortions for Writers are YOU guilty of?
1. Overgeneralization
You believe that because you've had one bad experience, the bad experience will always repeat itself in similar situations. Words like never, always, all, every, none, nobody, everyone are tip offs.
Example: "I always get bad reviews." "Nobody understands how hard I work." "I'll never write a bestselling book." "Everyone thinks my writing sucks."
2. Either/Or Thinking
Believing situations are always terrible or wonderful. You are either perfect or worthless.
Example: "If I can't publish this story, I'll never be able to write again." "This is my only chance to make a mark on the literary world. If they hate it, I'll never get another chance."
3. Rejecting the Positive
You focus on the negative and find reasons to devalue popular experiences or compliments.
Example: Your agent likes your new book and agrees to take it on, and you think, "it's just because she's having a slow year, and she probably won't be able to sell it anyway."
4. Focusing on the Negative
Selectively paying attention to the negative in a situation and disregarding the positive.
Example: Your book comes out to positive reviews -- except for the Washington Post, which calls it 'insipid and boring.' You focus on those adjectives exclusively (you even, in a cynical mood, make it your Tag Line at Red Room), and you forget about the seventeen printings and the thirteen glowing reviews.
5. Thinking Feelings are Facts
You believe that what you feel about life, situations, and people must be true.
Example: "I feel so unaccomplished. Those other Red Room authors are clearly better writers than I am." Or "I feel hopeless about my writing. I must have a disintegrating brain -- I will never be able to write a good book again."
6. Expecting Perfection
Making inflexible demands of yourself or others about how you "should," "must," "ought to" act. There is no allowance for variations in situations or changing conditions.
Example: "I should never feel jealous of other writers." "I ought to write every morning, I'm clearly a terrible writer because I don't."
7. Name-calling
Labeling yourself or others with a negative name or stereotype.
Example: "I'm a loser." "I'm not creative." "Editors are a bunch of blood-sucking, sadistic, insensitive writer-wannabes."
8. Feeling Controlled
Believing that you can't influence the most important things in your life. This belief can lead to blaming situations or others for your unhappiness.
Example: "What's the point of even sending my manuscript out? The industry is prejudiced against anybody who isn't this year's ethnic flavor of author." "Editors hate anybody who isn't a fresh, never-published-twenty-nine-year-old. That's why I'm drinking myself to death."
9. Feeling All-responsible
Believing you have control and responsibility for everything and everybody. You must fill every need and comfort every hurt; if you don't, you feel guilty. This thinking results in blaming yourself.
Example: "If I don't meet this deadline, the editors will have to work overtime and that will probably cause this small press to fold."
10. Hoping for Heaven's Reward
Expecting that personal sacrifice and self-denial will "pay off" in appreciation or returned favors. When this doesn't work, you feel resentful, hurt, or disappointed.
Example: "I worked for ten years on this book, refused paying work, and didn't take those sculpture classes I always wanted because I was writing so hard a book that I thought would change the face of American Literature. And nobody cares! Fuck them all!"
11. Comparing Worth
Thinking you are not good enough unless you are "as good as" someone else in all areas.
Example: "She knocked out two novels and a screenplay last year! I only got one small poem in print. I'm a terrible writer."
12. Always Expecting Disaster
You notice or hear about a problem or situation and anticipate the worst possible outcome.
Example: "I'm blocked this week. That means that I'll never write again, and I won't be able to earn a living, and I'll lose my house."
13. Predicting the Future
You make a negative prediction about how something will turn out or how someone will act.
Example: "Everybody's going to hate this book, it's too controversial."
14. Believing You Can Read Minds
Thinking you know what someone else is thinking or feeling without checking it out.
Example: "That bitch totally saw me in the audience at her reading and didn't say anything to me afterwards! She must think I'm a terrible writer."
-------
(I don't know who to credit for this list!!!! A version of this list was distributed as a handout by Kaiser Permanente in the Parent Support Wing of the Teen Depression group. This list (and Kaiser's handout) is based on the work of Albert Ellis, PhD., Aaron Beck, M.D., David Burns, M.D. and others. The terms and descriptions are from the Kaiser handout, but all examples -- made specific to writers -- are by me.)
- Login Or register To Post Comments
- Send To A Friend




Eric Nichols says:
I'm not angst-ridden enough
I guess I don't have enough internal grief to really be a great writer, if the powers that be are to be believed. I am, on occasion, capable of deep thought...honest! Just ask me! But, lurking just beneath this pensive, sensitive, contemplative exterior is my "inner flippant", just screaming to crawl out my pores. I really can't help it! I try to be deep, which works for a few paragraphs....sometimes a chapter or two. But there's always the punchline, burning in my bones. I dare not let any joke left unsaid, at peril to my very soul.
Eric
Ericka Lutz says:
no, no, good for you! Be happy!
Eric,
The most angst-ridden people I know are the stand-up comedians I used to hang out with years ago. Man, were they tortured. So I'm not sure there's neccessarily a relationship between how you write and how you feel. But if you don't feel bad, don't get all angsty about THAT...
Belle Yang says:
Very honest
and very scary. I think every writer goes through a period of depression and they ultimately pull out of it and, hopefully, never return to that state.
I went to bed thinking about your post and would like to write something later about how I see my own writing life.
BTW, I varied your oxtail soup recipe a tad and had two delish meals out of it. Thank you. Funny and interesting how you and Jessica inhabit my mind (and stomach) and we've never met.
I'm excited for you in that you have a whole new way of living and time to discover your writing life while your best friend is in Madagascar. Having listened to your podcasts, I know how talented and strong you are as a writer.
Ericka Lutz says:
I look forward to YOUR take on all this, Belle
And I love our online community, affecting our minds, hearts, AND stomachs. Yes, lots of new changes and adjustments for me... and I'm sure I'll blog (at least some of) them.
Kim Nicol says:
Great list
That's a great list -- and way too familiar! I'm glad to know it's not just me. I'm also glad for the idea that it needn't be like that.
Mickey B says:
Man, I'm depressed
Okay, I confess, I score off the Richter scale on all fourteen of these points. Maybe you could help an uber-depressed writer out and write a sequel to this piece: fourteen substitutions for depression distortions.
The worst part is that we brainy writers are especially capable of sneaky thinking to convince ourselves that these distortions are a hundred per cent true.
And of course I personally suffer from them worse than any other writer in the history of humanity.
Plus, what a writer does is so freakin' subjective. If I make airplanes, it's hard to argue I'm a failure once the airplane makes it off the ground. As a writer, there's always room to feel like a fraud, even if I have a best-seller on the market. Since I can't apply the laws of physics to art, there's always room to consider myself an incompetent fake who fooled some of the people most of the time.
Yikes! Make that monkey-mind stop!
P.S. -- This is a terrible comment. The last commenter did a MUCH better job. It's way too long. And it's not funny enough. See, I can't even write a decent comment, let alone a play. Ericka's not even going to okay it because it's so lousy. I don't know why I bothered....
Ericka Lutz says:
Mickey, I LOVE YOU
And I say that not JUST because I love you, if you know what I mean. You also crack me the hell up. I'll work on the substitutions....
Thomas Hancock says:
Cognitive Distortions
This looks like a variation on the list of Cognitive Distoritions used by cognitive therapists to correct the thinking that contributes to not only depression but other mental illnesses.
An even fuller treatment of this process is given in Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialectical_behavior_therapy, which is quite popular right now. It was originally created for the treatment of borderline personality disorder, but is now widely applied to a variety of illnesses. It borrows heavily from Buddhist psychology. The four modules of DBT are Mindfulness, Interpersonal effectiveness, Emotion Regulation, and Distress Tolerance.
But will getting all mentally "I'm OK, You're OK" make you a less-effective writer? Do you need to suffer? Although that's seems to be the common wisdom, the banal notion that a writer's work will reflect his or her experiences, whether predominantly good, bad or in between, seems more likely. Former U.S. Poet Laureate Ted Kooser (residing in my home state--woo hoo! a poet laureate not from the coasts!) said his upbringing was just fine, so that's at least one!