where the writers are

Grant Hayter-Menzies Biographer and historian

The reality of fiction

August 21, 2009, 10:34 am

I had a most interesting experience last week at the intersection of Fiction and Reality.  I was in Salem, Massachusetts to look at Chinese art objects at the Peabody Essex Museum - research for my new book project.  I had time to spare so I betook myself around Salem's harbour to the House of the Seven Gables.  Hawthorne's novel has been one of my favourites since childhood.  I grew up in what was, by California standards, a very old house, built in 1861 in the Greek Revival style, in a gold rush town that had seen better days.  Tracing the house's history was, for me, part of what made me into a historian.  That so many births, deaths, christenings and Christmases had happened in the house long before I was born fascinated me and gave the house a texture and atmosphere that I had only intuited.  I could only imagine if it were a house that had been in my family for centuries, like that of the Pyncheons in Hawthorne's tale - that those ghosts were my ancestors, reinforced by the occasional family portrait glowering from a parlor wall.  This was part of the fascination for me - also the fact that some of my ancestors had lived in houses like the seven gabled manse of the Pyncheons, in Massachusetts and Connecticut, and followed the same trajectory of sea captains to wealthy landed folk to finally abandoning the creaky old house for life far away from where their ancestors had first put down now very old and brittle roots.

I don't know what I was expecting at the House of the Seven Gables, but I came armed with my one hundred year old copy of the novel, which I had been re-reading with delight.  I have always loved one particular chapter in all the work of Virginia Woolf - the scene in the middle of "To The Lighthouse", in which the author's roving intelligence meanders through a house as time itself meanders across the landscape outside, lightening, darkening, lightening again the windows and the sea cliffs, and gravity enacts its slow theatre in the dropping from time to time of a tassel of a scarf thrown across a piano, far slower than the sunlight that creeps across the carpet and then retreats like a silver tide.  Woolf's novels are all experiments in different styles, some with more success than others.  This long poem on the passage of time, however, is one of her great masterpieces.  Yet didn't Hawthorne do exactly the same thing, in the middle of the nineteenth century, in the little red cottage, when he penned the chapter in "Seven Gables" in which the corpse of Judge Pyncheon sits motionless in the parlor of the old house as night falls and day slowly rises again to the windowsills to spill over into the deathly rooms?  I re-read this in utter terror and admiration, because nothing comes close to its cinematic snapshot of phantom Time, or its haunting depiction of Time as a stage in which the spirits of the dead may come to have their turn again, actors forever trapped in the roles they last played.  I expected, when I entered the house on Turner Street, that I would pick up at least some of this, even as Hawthorne had done when visiting his cousins in the house prior to writing the novel.

The House of the Seven Gables is, of course, a kind of Disneyland of Hawthorne's novel.  It inspired the book in part, but not all; it was opened for visitors in the 1900's, as part of a charitable undertaking for the benefit of Salem Settlement House, and many features were added to it to make it as much like the house in the novel as possible.  But I was not prepared for the benignant and venerable old mansion that I toured last week, in company with ten other people who, I was astonished to discover, had never read the novel.   It is just a house, with a lovely view to the Harbour, and gardens laid out to approximate those brought back to bloom by Hepzibah Pyncheon's young country cousin, Phoebe.  It creaks and cracks as you walk on its plank floors and you wouldn't wonder at its complaints.  A scrim of fiction has been stretched over it, painted with figures of people who never lived there, participants in dramas that never occurred.  Walking through the house gave me the sense of having awakened a pleasantly dozing old lady, who has had a long and busy life and more than deserves her nap in the sun. But the real revelation came when, still in the grounds, I found myself stealing glances into the novel, as a thirsty person takes swigs of water.  The reality of this fictional house lived not in four hundred year old beams and clapboards but in the yellowed pages of my 1905 edition of the novel.  This did not, of course, prevent me from picking up a stray bloom fallen on the garden path to press inside the pages of the book.  Flowers, like the fictional House of the Seven Gables, are both real and fantastical, impressing on the eye and nostril one day and gone the next, leaving memory.  Sort of like the power at the core of the greatest fiction, the kind Nathaniel Hawthorne gave us when he wrote "The House of the Seven Gables".

Jane Hammons

Jane Hammons says:

One of my favorite books!

One of my favorite books! Thanks for the wonderful description of the house and its connection to the book--and to your life and writing as well. I have a kind of obsession with place in fiction. I recently taught The Dying Ground by Nichelle Tramble to students at UC Berkeley. We took a bus down to College and Alcatraz in Oakland where an important scene takes place. Not quite The House of Seven Gables, but when you can bring the fictional world along for the ride, it definitely adds a layer to the experience of the "real" place.

Sharon Dreyer

Sharon Dreyer says:

Tell us more about your home and its relative ghosts.

Reading about your home as well as the House of Seven Gables was a delight. Can't believe that so many haven't read and enjoyed the novel; it's been a favorite of mine since I was a teen. Guess the novels used in the schools today are different. I hope to someday travel to Salem and the historical sites of the northeast seaboard. Thanks for sharing this great article. P.S. Did you ever run into any of your deceased relatives?

Ben Campbell

Ben Campbell says:

Thank you, Grant, for

Thank you, Grant, for writing about your crossroads experience. Like you I grew up in what was considered San Francisco standards in 1880, a splintered three story, Georgian Colonial farmhouse on the outskirts of SF in the Excelsior District. There was no resemblance to the old Pyncheon House appearance, but a few questionable events herald the farmhouse with mystery, and sometimes contempt. The house is the topic of my next novel.

I often ask friends and acquaintances how their childhood habitat and experiences influenced their adulthood. I presume yours was fantastical? Yes?

Ben Campbell
www.lulu.com/bencampbell

Grant Hayter-Menzies

Grant Hayter-Menzies says:

That old house

Hi Ben -

Thank you - I'm glad you enjoyed reading about my Salem epiphany. I love the idea of a house serving as basis for fiction or nonfiction, because as I wrote, I knew that my boyhood home had history in its bones. I knew that at least one person had died in the house; that in its better days it had been a place of music and laughter, flowers and flirtations. I knew that a sheriff had lived there, and that on the birth of his first child, a daughter, in the 1890's he had planted a white rose tree that was still there in my late 1960's childhood, and was remembered by that daughter, then a blind old lady who lived up the street. I knew that the furniture in her little house, which included a most marvelous Victorian settee with a beautiful human face carved into the crest-rail, had once been in our house. I knew, from climbing into the attic and seeing the original wallpaper, still visible from where the ceilings had been lowered, that what we used as a living room had been a parlor with walls rife with pink and blue sweetpeas set on stems of faded silver, hand-blocked in New York or Paris; and from elderly neighbours I knew that in the garden had once lived a massive old chow dog, belonging to an elderly maiden lady, with whom it was gentle but which, should a stranger approach, would try to tear one's head off. Sometimes, when my mother went to the store and left eight-year-old me in the house with my siblings, I wasn't the only one to hear strange whisperings - not so much of ghosts but of the layered energies of past loves, hates, births, deaths, all the vast array of human emotions that four walls and a ceiling can absorb over a century's time. It was largely because of that house that I became a biographer, because it taught me that every old house, like every person, has a story, and usually more than just one, and more than just one version of each. That a house, like a person, can be the prism through which we look into the past. Just yesterday I discovered that a house built by one of my Boston ancestors may still be standing in Old Saybrook, and I am working every resource I know to get a picture of it, to find out its condition and its fate. My forebears haven't lived there for almost three hundred years, but something tells me, when I see it, that it will teach me something about them. In fact, I'm sure of it!

Grant Hayter-Menzies

Tags: