It Isn’t Working: Jews Should Try Harder to Control the Newspapers
I am Jewish and (ahem) some of my best friends are Jews. A remarkable number of those friends are, well, high up in the news and publishing business. If there were, say, a “Jewish Conspiracy”to control the news to advance a particular agenda, my friends would be the ones having the secret meetings to make it happen.
I remember many years ago watching a grainy, videotaped speech by Louis Farrakhan, on a cable station in New Orleans, in which he introduced me to my now favorite offensive-conspiracy-vocabulary word: Jewspapers.
So, while these friends of mine are Jewish and have nice titles on their doors, the reality is that they are powerless over their own email inbox, back problems, former spouses’ continuingly inappropriate behavior, and the news and publishing business in general. I’d be surprised if they had any energy left to attend secret meetings when they can’t even make time for the gym.
If they really were powerful and able to stick to an agenda, I believe their agenda would be to lose a few pounds, go through those old boxes in the closet, and finally write the books they’ve always talked about writing. Not something oppressive to a segment of humanity. The mere suggestion of such a thing would cause any of my friends to spit out the water they were going to use to swallow their medication with.
So let’s turn our attention to a major newspaper that, in fact, is controlled by Jews. Openly pro-Israel Jews, even. Founded in 1918, it’s called Haaretz, and has the distinction of being Israel’s oldest Hebrew language daily newspaper. Maybe we should buy a gift subscription for Mr. Farrakhan. It’s a paper that tends to be read by educated Israelis, and is considered by some to be “The New York Times” of Israel because of its high-quality political, editorial, and cultural reporting. I don’t mean to conflate being Jewish religiously or ethnically with being Israeli citizens or with people who speak the Hebrew language. But I think it’s safe to say that the paper is controlled mostly by people who happen to be Jewish.
And here’s what those in power over this newspaper did on June 10th, 2009: They turned the newsroom over for one day to the novelists and poets of their country. Now, I know how much authors will take any excuse to procrastinate from finishing their upcoming novels, so I’m sure these authors were delighted to play journalist for a day. The special edition was created in conjunction with Hebrew Book Week and it created a little stir of awareness about writers.
According to Daniel Estrin of the Forward, http://www.forward.com/articles/107571/, the poet tasked with covering the weather wrote a poem about summer, the author tasked with covering the stock market wrote “Everything’s okay,” and a celebrated author suffering from cancer related touching scenes of other cancer patients. These unusual correspondents sometimes posed in the pictures with their subjects and often wrote in first person.
I read one story in which an author wrote about Netanyahu’s oration: “It was a speech for this watermelon season. A watermelon is 92 percent water, and so was this speech.”
I think The New York Times should hand over the newsroom to our American novelists and poets once a year, too, and my local San Francisco Chronicle should maybe do it every day. Now that I think about it, why not try this at Bloomberg.com? I will call my high-placed friends immediately and try to get an actual conspiracy going at these organizations.
Let the novelists and poets write the news and be in the photos, reflecting something different back, inspiring readers to think differently about their society. Haaretz turned their power over to a handful of uncontrollable artists brimming with imagination and individuality. And everything’s okay.
- Login Or register To Post Comments
- Send To A Friend



Steve Hauk says:
I think turning a newspaper over to poets and novelists
one day a year is a good idea, Ivory, as long as there's not a lot of corruption the day before that doesn't get covered. On the other hand, if the creative writers know of that corruption, their stinging critical prose or poetry might actually shame the miscreants, often thought to be an impossibility, in a way that reporters simply reporting the facts wouldn't.
Masha Hamilton says:
Yes to this idea!
Haaretz IS a great newspaper, and it is so cool that they did this. I think if Newsweek can turn over an issue to Steven Colbert, why not the NYTimes give a day to us? Or maybe, Ivory, you should take your Redroom authors and we should all write a single-edition Red Room newspaper one day?
Thanks for this, Ivory!
Oswald Pereira says:
Refreshing Indeed!
The Times of India has been doing something like this for quite sometime now. They nominate a celebrity such as a top actor, industrialist, or politician as the editor-in-chief for a day. The edition looks different as its front page, the editorial page, feature pages and the routine news pages reflect the preferences of the guest editor.
But I must confess that the outcome has never been as good as described by Ivory. It goes to show that handing over the newspaper to non-journalists for a day can turn out to be very refreshing.
Michael Lipsey says:
Ha'aretz
I get most of my news about Israel from Ha'aretz online. I especially like Rosner's columns. The present government is beyond maddening. I love Israel, but I really can't see their future -- they are hostages to their own religious fanatics, and risking alienating their only reliable ally to hold onto a few square mile of settlements.
Almost all the major American papers are losing money and circulation. I suppose we will get blamed for that too.
Michael Lipsey
Talia Carner says:
Jews to control the media?
Ivory,
How ironic that anti-Semites claim that Jews control the media, while Jewish insiders feel powerless to influence the media. I am in the latter group, and I, too, draw strength and knowledge from Ha'aretz. Thanks for introducing it to this audience.
Julie Stedman says:
Controlling the Media
Excellent perspective & objectivity. Thanks Ivory for sharing.
Julie