where the writers are

Jessica Barksdale Inclan Some say heartfelt and honest, some say Harry Potter for adults with sex.

Who is Behind the Narrator Curtain?


bibliomaniac

Amazon.com

  paperback
Amazon.com

Barnes & Noble

  paperback
Barnes & Noble

Powell's Books

  paperback
Powell's Books
More booksellers coming soon!

June 27, 2009, 7:59 am

My true belief is that a good writer can become whoever he or she wants to be.  No matter you are a gay white male from Poughkeepsie.  If you are worth your kosher salt, you can become an indigenous 12 year old girl from the inner Brazilian rain forest.  Somehow, you've done your research, gone into the trance that is writing, and pulled from that great mind of creativity.  There she is, in her perfection, this character we can all believe in.

I don't like the criticism that an African American woman can't write a white man or a white man can't write an African American woman.  that a straight white woman can't write a gay Latino man.  We start from the place of humanness, open our net, and write.

Now, some people just can't write.  Some people don't open that net.  some people stay in the place they are--holding fast and firm to their cultures and beliefs--and don't move enough to be able to write away from themselves.  It's not that this can't be done.  These folks just can't do it.

Give the same assignment to a skilled writer (be a four-year-old boy, now) and the writer can open, sink, and provide.

I'm having a light, happy summer festival of reading.  Actually, I was having that festival until my four classes started this week.  The music has stopped, and they are taking down the tents as I speak.  However, back a few days ago, I was plowing through Alexander McCall Smith's The No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency novels.

Granted, I am not from Botswana.  I am not a a Zimbabwe born Scottish man trying to channel a thirty-five year old Botswana woman.  I have never been to any part of Africa.  Actually, I am afraid of Africa (mostly because of snakes, scorpions, and diseases caught from various insects, not to mention bloody political coups and relentless drought and famine.).  But when I am reading these novels, I do not see or hear or feel the white male writer but the characters he's creating.  I am sure someone will take him to task for something, but in the world he's creating in the books, I'm there in the story with the main characters, feeling, I think, what they wold feel in the situations as they occur.

This is the miracle of writing, I think.  this ability to bring readers along into an imaginary, real world. 

As a reader, my promise to the writers of the books I pick up is that I will let you try to go anywhere.  I will let you become whoever you want to become.  Yes, I will make sure you are doing it, but once you show me the way, the clear, true way, I will follow.

Jessica

Mary Lynn  Archibald

Mary Lynn I. Archibald says:

Being Someone Else

Mary Lynn Archibald

Jessica,

I, too, believe that if you are a good enough writer you can become a person who has nothing at all to do with you except for scrupulous research and amazing creativity.

Not only that, but you can discover more about yourself in the process, because writing is also self-revelation if it is done right.

Vive la difference!

Jessica Inclan

Jessica Barksdale Inclan says:

Good point about the

Good point about the self-discovery part!  So true.

Best,

J

Jessica Barksdale Inclan www.jessicabarksdaleinclan.com

Dale Estey

Dale Estey says:

Part of me agrees with you,

Part of me agrees with you, and part of me does not. Just imagine the dialogue.

Jessica Inclan

Jessica Barksdale Inclan says:

Do the both of you need a

Do the both of you need a referee?

Best,

J

Jessica Barksdale Inclan www.jessicabarksdaleinclan.com

Louise Young

Louise Young says:

Jessica, I admire your ambition but --

I've done a lot of work with indigenous people in Panama, and I would never suppose to write anything from their point of view. It's not because of any racial thing or that I think that people from other cultures aren't alike in many ways, it's that, for many of them, their childhood and upbringing are just too different from mine. So much of one's thinking comes from childhood and when I see how the children in -- say, the Kuna culture -- are raised, I realize that there is no way that I can relate to growing up in that way. If people are from cultures that are roughly similar (say African Americans and European Americans), I don't think there is any problem, but I think that some cultural differences are too strong to overcome with reading and research. I've been working with the Kunas for 15 years and I still don't understand them sometimes!

Jessica Inclan

Jessica Barksdale Inclan says:

I think there is the knowing

I think there is the knowing from study and the knowing through something other--from that creative place that is not empirical or observational. I wonder if you made the attempt to write of these people whom you most certainly do know what would happen, I have read many miracles by other writers, as it was really not my ambition I was writing about but others'.

Best

J

Jessica Barksdale Inclan
www.jessicabarksdaleinclan.com

Bob Levin

Bob Levin says:

As an old writing professor

As an old writing professor of mine once said, "Shakespeare was neither a king nor a woman." On the other hand, I have pretty much proved to myself I am not Shakespeare.

Jessica Inclan

Jessica Barksdale Inclan says:

Have you worked on your

Have you worked on your iambs?

Best,

J

Jessica Barksdale Inclan www.jessicabarksdaleinclan.com

Bob Levin

Bob Levin says:

Not since the mock epic poem

Not since the mock epic poem (with rhymed couplets) I did senior year of high school on the West Philly - Overbrook game. But Anna Elsner has gotten me started on haikus

Jessica Inclan

Jessica Barksdale Inclan says:

So, you can be Basho insead

So, you can be Basho insead of shakespeare! Anything is possible.

Best,
J
Jessica Barksdale Inclan
www.jessicabarksdaleinclan.com