Why We Say What We Say
One of the most important writing tips I learned many years ago was that characters lie. They don't always say the truth. They say things in order to get out of trouble. "Duh," you say. "Like, um, where did you come from?" you say.
Well, here's the thing. I had never felt so honest as when I was writing. The truth in all its ugliness and scary consequences could come out. How people feel--it had to be true and real. How people thought--the utter, stark truth. My characters were like fonts of reality, shining bright from their plot lines, saying all that was true and ruining the damn story.
"Lie," a teacher said. "Let them lie."
So they started lying. They lied as a way to get out of paying the price of their own actions. They lied in order to get another character to do something. They lied because they were most ashamed of their behavior and wanted to make themselves look better. They lied to pit two other characters against each other. They lied, just as people do, all the time.
Maybe I had too much lying at first, but then things calmed down. And then lying took subtle turns, turning more into obfuscation and omission sometimes. But it helped. It was real. It made the story better.
Lying in life, though, usually doesn't help, or at least it feels that way. I have lied myself up a storm in my 46 years, and I am sure I will do it again. In fact, I'm going to lie today, it seems. Some studies have shown that one fourth of our daily interactions involve lying, varying from outright falsehoods to the smaller omissions and feints. We lie to avoid conflicts and to avoid hurting other people's feelings. We lie on the phone. We lie face-to-face. Men and women lie in the same percentage, saying two or three lies per day. (that's a lie--it's really 1 or 2. I was just testing you and your math skills).
But when the lie is found, caught in the cross hairs of relationship, lies hurt. They make us bleed a little. Sure, they add tons to a plot line, but not to our lives, really. We are caught, have to confess or staunchly refuse to--that refusal causes more grief and the confession sounds like a plea for mercy. For those who are lied about, well, how do we defend ourselves against one? Truly, I think the best offense is no offense. Let it go. The person who lied about us needed the lie, and we can't really do much more than wait. We shouldn't take out billboards to proclaim our innocence, or we end up like the Player Queen in Hamlet, Gertrude telling us all, "The lady doth protest too much." And the basic truth is that the truth will out, as it always does, god dammit!
Lies are part of our life, the big ones and the ones that sound like, "I love that dress."
I am going to see if today I can go out and say what is true all day, even when my students read a bad essay to me. Even when I am asked at a party I'm going to tonight how my school year went.
"Bad essay," I will say. "This semester sucked."
I can see why we lie already.
Jessica
- Login Or register To Post Comments
- Send To A Friend
RSS- Bookmark With:







Belle Yang says:
Great Essay
Someone in a blog asked us to be mean to our characters and now you ask us to make them lie. Oddly, when you asked about my list of future blogs. One of them was about lying. I broke off my relationship with my neighbor for her extravagant lying to others, and she asked us to lie right along with her, so she also corralled me and my family into the nebulous web. Just awful. We were too "nice" to say no at the time. Too slow to react. It's one thing when you yourself have to lie; it's another when you force another person, a friend, a neighbor, to lie along with you. ARRRGH.
Just makes me so sick thinking about it. But it sounds like a fun prospect when I get back to writing fiction to make my characters awful, miserable liers. Then I'll throw a rock on top of them to punish them for doing so.
I'm rubbing my hands like your squirrels in delight.
P.S.--I ran off in a tizzy after reading this and responded to your blog in my own blog.
P.P.S.--thick-skinned people lie.
Jessica Barksdale Inclan says:
I am going to go read it now!
Lying is an amazing topic. I did some math. According to the research, I have lied 24,780 times in my life. It's unbelievable. It's a lie!
Anyway, I look forward to learning more about moon cake woman and the culture of lying.
J
Jessica Barksdale Inclan www.jessicabarksdaleinclan.com
Eric Nichols says:
One done, nine to go
Hi Jessica!
You can scratch blog topic number one off my top ten list. See my member blog "Who has'ma Plasma." Pass this on to Belle if you see her before I do. :)
Comments welcome and solicited, of course!
eric