where the writers are

Lisa Shearin National bestselling fantasy adventure

Plot a book? Or fly by the seat of your pants?

May 13, 2009, 4:09 am

It's constantly debated in writing circles, and every author has their favorite method. Write a full plotline before beginning, or write the book by the seat of your pants?

Me? I like the security blanket of a full plot outline. That being said, I usually stick to the basic framework of whatever plot outline I come up with, but it changes. Once I get into a book, new and better ideas pop up and push aside what I thought would have worked back when I was writing the synopsis. And yes, once you're published, a synopsis (or outline) is required for your agent to send to your editor to sell the next book(s). This is usually accompanied by the first three chapters of the book. But after my second book with Anne Sowards (my editor at Ace Books), she's fine with just a synopsis. She knows that I can deliver the book and doesn't need sample chapters to tell her that.

However, for Bewitched & Betrayed, the plot outline that I sent to Anne was pretty sketchy, like an Impressionist painting -- you could tell what the book would look like, but the details were kinda left up to the imagination. Yep, B&B is being written by the seat of my pants and I think it's going very well. The same was true with Armed & Magical. I had a detailed plot outline, but after determining that it didn't work, I ditched the entire thing and wrote the book from scratch based on a one-paragraph synopsis. It was my first National Bestseller.

So what is the best way? Plotter? or Pantster? Most authors, including myself, will tell you that it's a combination of both. It's good (and I believe necessary) to know approximately where your book will end, but there are plenty of ways to get there (much like a roadtrip). Don't go too far off the beaten trail, but don't be afraid to take a couple of interesting-looking left turns.
 Upcoming blog topics based on your questions:

  • Making the magic work, or at least make sense.
  • How long should you prepare before starting a book?
  • How much time should you spend developing a character?
  • Am I moving my story forward?
  • How do I figure out what happens next?
  • Keeping your hopes up while looking for an agent.
  • Writing in the moment.
  • "Framing" your book.

Tags: