where the writers are

Lisa Solod Warren I am constantly re-inventing myself through both fiction and non-fiction.

Great News for Writers Who Have Nothing to Say!

September 22, 2009, 7:00 am

All of you writers and would-be writers who have never been sexually abused by your parents, suffered from domestic assault, been abandoned on a highway somewhere by grandparents when raising you got to be too much; any of you who have never suffered from anorexia or bulimia, are not cancer survivors, who have never had a child addicted to drugs, or lost a child before his time; those of you who have not been addicted to anything at all; and those of you who haven’t had the misfortune of having your spouse leave you for a member of the same sex, who haven’t  suffered from any mental illness (even a minor one); as well as the few of you who have never suffered deprivation of any kind (sorry, if you had your lunchbox stolen in grammar school you do not qualify) or did not lose money in the crash, whose parents are not famous and fucked up; any of you who are not blind go-go dancers or quadriplegic painters, or authors who compose with your eyelashes; and, of course, those of you who were not child prodigies, and all of you who have never bothered to suffer for one moment the pain of self contemplation. All of you writers who live comfortable lives in the suburbs where the most pressing problem is where to go for dinner, and last but not least, all of those of you who are not from another country which you had to flee because of poverty, war or mutilation –HAVE WE GOT AN OFFER FOR YOU!

No longer in vogue are memoirs centered around angst or pain or loss.  The publishing industry is so over that.

No…. according to an acid-tongued review in the Sunday New York Times Book Review, all you have to do now to get a book contract to write about your life—or some small part of it—is be totally, utterly boring and have a decent upper middle class life about which you do only the most mundane of contemplating.

Sound easy?  Not so fast.  Although Knopf, one of the most respected houses in the industry, bought the (apparently) slender memoir, the scathing assessmentof it by book reviewer Ada Calhoun may cause the publisher pause in this new experiment to publish books in which absolutely nothing happens and no catharsis or epiphany is reached. ( I would caution you to write your tome very quickly.)

To wit:  “Gideon’s memoir opens with a scene in front of her son’s school.  The carpool line ultimate prompts her to wonder,  ‘Is this all there is?’ Other triggers for existential angst:  her 9-year-old’s first trip to camp, her dog’s death and the difficulty of finding a mattress both she and her husband like on a budget of $3,000.”

Sound riveting?

The reviewer goes on to tell us that the author is having “what may well be the least dramatic mid-life crisis in American history.  She doesn’t start drinking, traveling or sleeping around. Nor does she get a job, adopt a baby or even do charity work.  The scope of what is not done in the course of this book boggles the mind. It’s like an addiction memoir minus the addiction or a tell all without the all.”

I don’t know about you, but I am panting to get to a bookstore and buy the book right this minute.

As soon, of course, as I finish reading the review again, which seems, even at second or third glance, far more interesting and lively than the book itself.

And please don’t lecture me about finding out for myself if the book is as bad as the reviewer says it is.  I don’t care.

 I am just thrilled that finally all the boring people with no lives and no quest for a life—and there must be tons of them-- can get a book published.

I don’t know about you but I sure was getting  tired of those other memoirs where people triumphed over pain and anguish or discovered love in the arms of a foreign stranger, or married a better man than the one who left them.  I  was just sick to death of reading about all that tsuris.*

This year I am only seeking out memoirs in which absolutely nothing happens, is accomplished, thought about or considered. So before the next bad review comes out and the publishers have a change of mind:  get thee to a computer.

Because soon enough a reviewer will  say that the book discussed above is “a breath of fresh air” and everyone will be running to get in on the act.  

  

*Tsuris is Yiddish for big trouble.

Gina Collia-Suzuki

Gina Collia-Suzuki says:

I almost did absolutely

I almost did absolutely nothing about ten years ago. If only I'd tried harder and actually managed to do it, I could be facing hitting the big time right about now. I do have a tin of paint around here somewhere. If I have the time, I'll paint a wall and watch it dry... perfect material for an overnight hit by the sounds of it.

Lisa Warren

Lisa Solod Warren says:

I absolutely agree

I, too, wish I had had a wonderful upbringing with no trauma and that I had just been a slacker all my life or married rich and been a Hollywood wife. Sigh.....

Lisa Heeren

Lisa Heeren says:

NIce! So appropriate. Lisa

NIce! So appropriate.
Lisa Heeren

John Oughton

John Parker Oughton says:

This is a very funny... a

This is a very funny... a fitting celebration of a review etched in acid. For some reason, it reminds me of a line by Dorothy Parker after watching a performance by Katharine Hepburn "Miss Hepburn runs the gamut of emotions from A to B."
Another thought is that some intrepid researcher will discover, horrifying Oprha (who loved this book), that "Gideon" in fact indulged in some flights of the imagination in order to create a less dramatic memoir, leaving out the part where at 18 she performed in a hoochie-ccochie show, fell for a heroin-abusing roustabout, and got kidnapped by the Hells Angels." Instead, she claimed then to have been starting a degree in "niceness" at Middle U.

Lisa Warren

Lisa Solod Warren says:

Thanks

and very clever of you. In this day and age completely possible.

Louise Marley

Louise Marley says:

Thanks for a chuckle.

The sorts of things which get published--without editorial input, evidently--never cease to amaze. I think your post is far more entertaining than the book must be!

Merle Huerta

Merle Huerta says:

Very funny satirical post. . .

Perhaps the publishers are simply trying to find a profitable venue where they can publish memoirs but can avoid slander suits. Seems like too many memoirists (Frey, Burroughs, etc.) have been fictionalizing their lives, or at the least are being accused of it. Does seem to ruin it for the rest of us poor, unpublished writers who have tremendous "tsuris" and have emerged victorious. Perhaps the key is to paint a traumatic life with a mundane lens, as if the trauma and chaos is happening around the author, but that the author is somehow detached and completely sane and composed.

Katherine McWilliams

Katherine McWilliams says:

I thoroughly enjoyed reading

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this. It gives me such hope. Swift would be proud.

Angeline Scott

Angeline Scott says:

Book Publishing Finally Catches Up to 'Seinfeld'

What a great post! What a 'relief' to know that book publishing has finally caught up to television, albeit 10 years too late, and the Seinfeldian notion of 'media about nothing'.

Seems to me that rather than buckling to the mundane, the industry would be better off turning to history to save it. Or at the very least, look at what's happened to the music industry - cranking out uninspired drivel and expecting that the masses will buy into it because they are repeatedly told 'how good it is'. This clearly doesn't work...

At the risk of being considered 'old fashioned', I'd suggest that getting back to basics might be a reasonable start. Good writing, is just that, good. In the end, you can't fool readers, we know when we are being conned.

Thanks for the piece!

David Beemer

David Beemer says:

Wait a minute!

Wait a minute! I was with you until you discussed the difficulty of finding a mattress both significant others can agree upon for less than three thousand dollars. Such a thing cannot be found at any price. Less angst if you just get separate bedrooms.

Lisa Warren

Lisa Solod Warren says:

I am thrilled that this

I am thrilled that this touched some of you! And, perhaps, David, you are ultimately right:)

Kimberly Jackson

Kimberly Jackson says:

Very Enjoyable

I found this post very enjoyable. It gave me a little chuckle.