Susan Browne "Buddha’s Dogs is filled with the beauty and the burning of lived experience." --Edward Hirsch

The Truth Hurts

September 30, 2008, 10:44 am

What if we were to tell the truth?  Exactly what we really think.  This would not work in many situations.  For example, yesterday, I wanted to tell an online student:

You are a rude little twerp, as well as a pain in the ass.  Get your shit together or drop the class. 

The student had emailed me to let me know she "forgot" about the class.  She's just been too busy, so she "forgot."

Her amnesia is not my problem.   Can you imagine telling your professor in college that you "forgot" you had a class?

Then the student wanted me to figure out her grade for the rest of the semester so she could decide whether she should drop the class or not.  I told her that would not be possible because who knows what her grades would be on all her assignments when she finally remembers to do them.  I was also truthful and said it was not my responsibility, the fact that she "forgot" she had a class, and now I had to do more work so she could make her important decision.  She could do that on her own, and I shouldn't be addressing this ridiculous situation in the first place.  She wrote me back a long diatribe that was even more rude and insulting.  I responded with a professional letter that said, in essence, her goose was now completely cooked, and I had sent her emails to the Dean; the student needed to send me an apology and drop the class. 

She apologized.  She said I had misinterpreted her emails.  I said no, I did not, and that I accepted her apology.

But the truth is I really don't accept her apology.  And the truth is she's not sorry.  She just realizes that she will get thrown out of the college if she doesn't apologize.  The truth is I hate this part of my job.  I hate it so much, and I have hated it for years and years and years and years.

The truth is that students who act like this cause more work for everyone.  The truth is I shouldn't have to listen to shit like this.

The truth is I don't want to teach in a community college anymore.  I only want to teach students who are ready, who are passionate about learning.  I want to teach small groups of students who love the subject of literature and writing.  I am as tired as a slow painful piss in hell of teaching people who can barely speak the language, or who don't give a damn about the language, about reading and writing.  When students tell me they don't "like" the short story by Flannery O'Connor or Gabriel Garcia Marquez, this is what I want to say:  "I don't give a flying rat's fuck what you "like."

God, that feels good to say.  And I don't apologize for it.  That's the truth.

I'm going to speak the truth all day today.  I probably shouldn't leave the house.  But I'm going to.  The truth!  Emily Dickinson said, "The truth is so rarely heard, it is a delight to tell it."

Is that really true, Emily?  She also said, "Tell all the truth, but tell it slant."

I'm tired of the slanted truth.  I'm telling it straight on, all the livelong day today.  A teacher who tells the truth!  Not Ms. Fucking Mamby Pamby.  That's over, folks. 

Jennifer Gibbons says:

Susan, all I can tell you is this...

remember that bumper sticker in your office: "Don't let school get in your way of a education."

Susan Browne says:

Hi Jennifer

I never have and I never will!

Dale Estey says:

Because I Could Not Stop For Death

Now that you have scorched all potential of entering politics or becoming a preacher - how is the day?

Susan Browne says:

Hello Dale

The day is great.  "What is madness but nobility of soul at odds with circumstance?  The day's on fire!  I know the purity of pure despair."

Words of my great love, Theodore Roethke.

Dale Estey says:

Going To Bat For The Truth

For something is amiss or out of place
When mice with wings can wear a human face.

Eric Nichols says:

I always loved the Jim Carey

I always loved the Jim Carey movie, Liar Liar. :)

Eric Nichols says:

"You are a rude little

"You are a rude little twerp, as well as a pain in the ass. 

Get your shit together or drop the class."

Your meter is a tad off.  :)

Eric

Eric Nichols says:

Don't give up on community

Don't give up on community college just yet.   I actually came away with a GENUINE  EDUCATION in science and technology from El Camino.  I learned a LOT more there than any subsequent education I received.  Of course, this might have been an exception....I consider myself somewhat self-educated...and perhaps, therefore, highly motivated.

Then again, by the time I was out of high school, I was already literate and marketable.  As were many of my peers.

 Education can be wasted on people at every level...from dropouts to PhDs.  I don't know if there's a way of knowing ahead of time.  Probably the best determination is if the student is PAYING for his class himself....which usually only happens when they're already a productive adult. :)

Eric Nichols says:

New improved meter...or metre....

You're a rude little twerp, a pain in the ass,

You must gather thine shit, or forsake the class.

There....much better.

 Your bill is in the mail :)

eric

Susan Browne says:

Eric

I prefer:

You are a rude little twerp and a pain in the ass.

Get your shit together or get out of the class.

*.

 4/4 accentual meter.  It's simple, works perfectly, and gets the message across.

Yes, I know ALL about teaching at the community college.  I've had great students, and a great time.  But sometimes it feels right and good to tell the whole truth.  There are parts of the job that are just plain awful.  Like most jobs.

Veronica Chater says:

What a great post. Mind if I

What a great post. Mind if I borrow "I don't give a flying rat's fuck what you 'like'," with my eighth graders? The kids might crack up, but it probably wouldn't go over too well with their parents. Maybe I could use it with my own kids? Hmmmm. They might be damaged for life.

Who really appreciates hearing the truth? Certainly not a student who "forgot" she signed up for a course because she had no interest in it in the first place.

 "It takes two to speak the truth. One to speak, and another to hear." Thoreau

I attended your poetry class at DVC back in the eighties. I loved your class. I will never forget the spirit and energy and love for language you brought to the class. You inspired me. I also took Clark McKowen (remember him?) and loved his class. Because of teachers like you and Clark I went on to get a master's in English and to pursue a career in writing. Don't let a snotty online student get you down. There are plenty of students who appreciate what you give them.

Susan Browne says:

Veronica!

Thank you so much for commenting.  Wow.  This is great news to hear.  You went on to teach English and write.  I am so happy.  It brings the good old tears to my eyes.  (But no, they don't roll gently down my cheek! Cliche!) 

Yes, Clark McKowen was the best teacher I have ever seen light up a classroom.  My life would not have been the same without him, personally and professionally.

Thanks again for writing this.  It made a difference.

Veronica Chater says:

Susan!

Teachers need to know that the work they do matters. I was the quiet type, afraid to speak up. It took time and maturity to make me realize how indebted I was to teachers like you. You gave me a gift, and I never thanked you. I want you to know that the murmur among all my English major friends was, "You've GOT to take Susan Browne. She's SO cool. Her classes are REALLY interesting, AND she's a published poet."

Because of you I published a haiku in "Agape" (is that what the journal was called?) It was my first ever published piece, the embryonic stage of a (hopefully) long career in writing. A real life success story. My memoir, "Waiting for the Apocalypse," is coming out in February with WW Norton. It's about my life before DVC (my family lives in Pleasant Hill), but if I write a part two, you'll definitely be included as one of my early influences. 

Susan Browne says:

Veronica,

I just read your blogs Politics & Religion and Truth & Memoir: both great pieces!  I can't wait to read your memoir.  Yes, I have a blog here about Parental Literary Criticism--my father's response to my first poetry book which has many poems dealing with our family life.  His response was surprising, truly unpredictable.

My first novel, (I'm still seeking an agent), is based on some of the past situations with my parents.  I wanted to write fiction instead of memoir, to take more liberties with the story.  The novel took me many years to write, turning into two completely different novels.  What a process.

Thanks so much for your comments.  I love knowing you took the path from DVC to all this wonderful writing.