Red Room Where the Writers Are

Comments I've Written

• Problems so fundamental, its difficult to proceed

  Christie: The problem with defining racial categories is that they routinely devolve into tautology.

• Post Script - will respond in some time

  Mr. Christie: For an awful lot of whites, Jews are not "white"

• Re:

  Mr. Christie: Nit-picking..It really shows your desperation..

• Re:

  We're already ground in a far more mundane discussion on the other thread. However, if you feel you can attach causality to any of your statements there, feel free.

• Space

  Tim Wise: I don't have time to go thru and answer all the critiques David, and others have done a pretty good job I feel of defending the paradigm in the original piece.